Friday, September 7, 2012

PLQ leadership


Here is my list of possible candidates:

Jean-Marc Fournier - MNA - Montreal Area
Nathalie Normandeau - Former MNA - Gaspe
Marlene Jennings - Former MP - Montreal area
Liza Frulla - Former MP - Montreal area
Martin Cauchon - Former MP - Montreal area *
Denis Coderre - Former MP - Montreal area *
* = May chose to run Federally.


Longshots:
Stephane Dion - MP - Montreal area
Jean Lapierre - Former MP - All over the place
Pierre Pettigrew - Former MP - Montreal area
Justin Trudeau - MP - Montreal area


Thursday, September 6, 2012

Libs hold Vaughan, lose Kitchener

The Liberal Party of Ontario has managed to hold on to the Vaughan ridings by a wide margin, but has lost it's attempt to grab Kitchener-Waterloo from the Tories.

At the time of this post, Kitchener-Waterloo has 20% of the polls in, and the NDP leads the PC Party, 43% to 30%. It's still a bit to early to call, but, things should become very clear by 10pm. I will edit in more counts below.


edit
With a third of the polls in, I've seen enough, and am declaring an NDP victory.

Where I was wrong




Ridings where I was wrong, but within the margin of error (12)
Berthier
Masko
Argentuil
Riviere Du Loup
Orford
Megantic
Soulanges
Jean Lesage
Mille Isles
Vmont
Fabre
Groulx


Ridings where I was just plain wrong where the model, after adjustments, is correct. (3)
Trois Rivieres
Anjou
Bellechasse


Ridings where I was just plain wrong where the model, even after adjustments, is within the margin of error. (8)
Cote De Sud
Becuase Sud
St. Henri
Verdun
Huntingdon
Richmond
Nicolet
Laurier


Ridings where I was just plain wrong where the model, even after adjustments, is still just plain wrong. (3)
La Prairie
Johnson
Chateauguay









Model on Results


Further adjustments:
50% of the ADQ vote given to the Liberals
Aussant Factor increased to 25,000 due to CAQ adjustment
N Shore set to 0
S Shore set to .4

Results:
PQ - 58
PLQ - 42
CAQ - 23
QS - 2


Full file here
https://docs.google.com/open?id=0B5UDSiORyjxid1I2bHdic21Hc3c
Click above

Quebec Results




Putting in the real final popular vote into the ElectoMatic, I also had to make the following adjustments:


ON did not gain any "Student Votes"
"Student Factor" set at 200, 650 gives better results.
"Aussant Factor" set at 13,500, should have been set at 11,050
CAQ took .31 less than ADQ in QC area, set at .45
CAQ took .47 more (than ADQ) in N Shore, set at .2
(CAQ) took .41 more in Montreal, set at .27
took .28 more in south shore, set at .0
"Anglo Factor" set at 35%, with "Montreal Factor" at 0.78, Both should have been set at 0

These results give
PQ - 48
PLQ - 44
CAQ - 31
QS - 2
ON - 0

The CAQ is still winning far too many seats, indicating to me that the fault is with transfering 100% of the ADQ numbers to the CAQ.

I will try that and report back.

Ontario By-Elections

Polls close at 9pm, and I will hopefully be able to live-tweet all the results, but something may come up.

Vaughan is expected to be a close race between the Liberals and Tories, but the Liberals seem to have the edge.

Kitchener-Waterloo seems to be a close 3-way race, where no party has the edge.

Wednesday, September 5, 2012

New Schedule

Due to my inability to keep to the old schedule, I'm writing a new one.

First off, I should explain a bit more about my cat (Boo) and what has happened to him.
In March, my Roomate (whom I shall call Kris) noticed that Boo was peeing a lot, much more than usual. She decided to test his urine and it came back positive for sugar - something not normal. We called a vet and the vet tested Boo's blood, and turns out he has Diabetes. We gave him insulin, tested multiple times a day, and switched his diet. He went into remission in June
.
In late July, Kris and I noticed that Boo was throwing up at about the same time every morning. We could not figure out why. A week or so later, Kris noticed Boo not acting normal, and we again called the vet who ran a number of tests. We were referred to another vet, and from there to another. We eventually found out that Boo has a combo of Irritable Bowel Disease, Fatty Liver Disease, Pancreatitis, and inflamed intestines. This is a very bad combination, as the treatment for any one of them (pain killers, for the Pancreatitis, for example) makes another worse (constipation) and other drugs can't be processed due to the Liver problems.

We had a feeding tube put in, and since then, have been feeding Boo though the tube using a syringe. The process of feeding takes about 15 minutes and Boo is sometimes resistant. In addition, he throws up once or twice a day, and can only eat so much at one time. Due to possible feeding tube damage when he vomits and the need to get a minimum of food in to him so he can physically survive, this means he needs to be monitored 24 hours a day.

Kris and I have been doing so. More her than I actually, as she knows much more about medicine, and I have a bad habit of passing off work to others when I can. We've agreed that we would take "shifts" of 10 to 10. From 10pm to 10am, I am "on duty". The idea is for me to be awake during these hours, and sleeping during the remainder. Since I only need 8 hours sleep, the exact timings are flexible. We may change these timings (for example, to 6 to 6, with me still on the "night shift") but in general, I'm awake at night.

At least, that is how things are supposed to go.

I've been feeling ill recently. I finally got a family doctor, the first in my adult life. He told me that my Asthma was flaring up. The difficulty in breathing was making me sleep much more than 8 hours (due to poor quality sleep) and this put stress on Kris, which in turn, but stress on me (I was not choosing to sleep all day long) The new medication that the doctor gave me however seems to be having the opposite effect, in that now I can not get to sleep. Due to these things, my sleeping has been all over the place, and when awake, I've been having difficulty concentrating. Now that the election is over, and Kris begins at university, our schedules are getting more set, and I will hopefully be able to get into a normal routine.

The schedule for the new few days is therefore "get into a routine". This is not very good for posting on a blog however. Therefore I will commit to the following.

My first goal is to finish gathering and sorting the data from the election. Once that is done, I will examine where I went wrong, and compare my results to that of other projectors. None of us did very well, but I may have done worse than average. I will examine the reasons why.

I'll take the real data and I will examine it in comparison to my projection. My goal here will be to find ways to adjust the model to better match the results. I suspect that I can do this somewhat easily by taking a third of the ADQ vote and applying it to the PLQ.

Sometime before the Ontario By-Elections I will make a post about it. I will also live-tweet the results.

Once all that is done, I will have to make a serious change to the ElectoMatic, the most serious change ever made. In the post explaining it, I will describe the "Ratio" system I use, and how it is much better than the "Flat" system used by others. I will also explain how I will add a new "Swing" method to the mix.

Once that is complete, I will take the new model out for a few test runs, putting in past election results (IE 1979 federal) and past result popular vote numbers (IE 1980 federal) and seeing how well it works. I will continue to tweak it until I get it to work as close to reality as possible. I will also focus on trying to estimate huge swings (1980 to 1984 federally in Quebec, or 1988 to 1993 in Western Canada) and anything else I think could be useful.

After that, we'll have to see what is going on in politics!

Brian Pallister elected as Manitoba Leader of the Opposition

Pallister, Manitoba PC leader, has won a by-election, becoming the new Leader of the Opposition.
http://electionsmanitoba.ca/2012Fortwhyte/results/division.asp

Analysis to continue

I've woken up feeling refreshed and will continue my analysis shortly. I will also focus on why the model failed (in short, ADQ voters voting Liberal) and why I failed (I saw the polls indicating this would happen but did not want to believe them)

Yet another delay

I can't get my mind off the assassination attempt, and am having trouble focusing on the numbers. I've also been very sleep deprived recently, and that is not helping. Regardless, the numbers I have right now are as follows.

Northern Quebec
PQ - 107,261 - 48.88%
PLQ - 51,188 - 23.33%
CAQ - 45,696 - 20.82%
QS - 9,025 - 4.11%
ON - 3,637 - 1.66%
PVQ - 276 - 0.13%
Aut - 2,371 - 1.08%

I also have a map showing which regions I am using.

Analysis of Final Results

Coming in the next minutes to hours.

Final Results

Yup, there's still an election to finish counting.

Marois Assassination attempt?

As the new premier-elect was finishing her speech, a security person rushed her off the stage suddenly.

2 minutes later, some PQ operatives came on stage, saying that they had to protect her as something happened. He then asked everyone to leave.

1 minute or so later, Marois came back and said the same thing. She mentioned a sound grenade.

3 minutes later there is news footage of a man lying on the pavement and a rifle.

What
The
Hell

I've never seen anything like this before and probably never will again.

If this was an assassination attempt I have one thing to say

I hate the PQ, and Marois. I think they are potentially dangerous.
But they won.
They won the election, fair and square.
No matter how much you hate or fear the other guy, you can't try to stop them by force.
Democracy is the cornerstone of our freedom, and we must respect it, even when it tells us the things we don't want to hear.

Tuesday, September 4, 2012

Counting Continues


Where things stand (updated)

Fixed a few errors, updated other ridings.


Where things stand

Note blank ridings are where the winner is still not clear.

So what happened


Quoting from a previous post about the CAQ heartland, south of Quebec City.



"If the PLQ starts winning big here and the CAQ is still managing to find seats somewhere, it means the old ADQ voter has split between the CAQ and PLQ. ."


More analysis later on, of course, as well as full results (eventually)

PROJECTION CHANGE

As the counts come in it is starting to become more and more clear that the PLQ will take near it's projected maximum.

Our projection is now for a PQ minority based on counts that have come in.


We will examine where we went wrong overnight.

PQ will not win a majority

PLQ vote just too strong

PLQ to take near maximum

PLQ to take near their projected maximum.

Last minute change

Live blogging is to become live tweeting.

http://twitter.com/thenewteddy


Bump - Final

POLLS HAVE CLOSED!







Timings

Live Blogging will begin when the polls close. I've chosen to make a new post every few minutes.

Things to keep an eye on.

What should you keep an eye out for as the results roll in?

Sherbrooke

Jean Charest should lose by a convincing margin. The first 10 or 20 polls in any riding can show just about any result, just ask the leader of the Quebec wing of the Marxist-Leninists (who was shown leading in his federal riding in 1997, based on 1 poll) Beyond 20 polls however things get a bit more stable. At that point here is what you should see: Charest trailing. Maybe Charest jumping into the lead for a few minutes, but going back to trailing. Here is what you should not see: Charest ahead, and staying ahead. If you do see the latter it is a sign that the PLQ Campaign has done far better than expected. A Charest win in his riding should spell a PLQ minority government.


Anglo-Montreal

The PLQ should sweep the ridings in West Island Montreal. The PQ is certainly not going to sweep them and there is no evidence that either the QS or ON has managed to appeal to them in large numbers. If the CAQ starts winning seats here all bets may be off. The CAQ is not expected to take the Anglo vote, and if it does, it could decimate the PLQ, and, possibly thrust itself into government as a result. 


Franco-Montreal

Areas of Francophone Montreal are expected to split between the PQ and PLQ. The QS is expected to take Mercier and Gouin. The QS could have a strong shower in Laurier-Dorion, Sainte-Marie--Saint-Jacques, and Outremont. They may also do well in Rosemont, and Hochelaga--Maisonneuve. ON is expected to do well around these areas too. Should the QS start leading in any of these ridings (past 20 polls) and hold on to the lead, they may well be able to win the riding, and the same goes for the ON. This would be on the strength of the Student vote, and those whom the Students have convinced to follow them.


South of Quebec City

Parts south of Quebec City (Beauce, Bellechasse, Arthabaska, Levis, etc) are expected to be the heartland of CAQ support. If the PLQ starts winning big here and the CAQ is still managing to find seats somewhere, it means the old ADQ voter has split between the CAQ and PLQ. If, however, the PLQ sweeps this area and the CAQ is doing awful, it means the CAQ has failed to find new voters and has lost old ADQ voters.


Saguenay

The PQ is expected to sweep all the ridings in this area (Chicoutimi, Dubuc, Jonquiere, Lac-Saint-Jean, Roberval, even Rene-Levesaue, and Duplessis) a failure to do so would indicate all the existing projection models have a flaw and other areas of supposed PQ strength could be equally misleading.


Notre-Dame-de-Grace

The PVQ has had an awful campaign, only finding candidates in half the ridings. This is their best riding in the province, and, the leader has chosen to run here. The lower the vote share for the PVQ in this riding, the longer it will take to rebuild the party.


Levis

Perhaps the most interesting "smaller party" this election is the new provincial Conservative Party lead by former MP Luc Harvey. He is running in Levis and is not expected to do well. You can gawk at him in this riding as the results come in.